Tuesday, 24 February 2015

Solutions based on Cultures

HI PEEPS! I know it's already in the middle of the night, but im still all pumped up to do this blog! well actually it's because i woke up super late today, HAHA. Anyway, this week topic has something to do with culture. And, because my chosen topic is "too many cars" so it is about finding solutions from our cultures, well, my culture in this case. For all you don't know I am Indonesian and so I will pick something related with Indonesian cultures.

Initially there wasn't that many cars in indonesia. It only changes in these past decades. But then that would make a quite straight forward answer since that makes no available solution related to my culture for this problem. But then let us see the past transportation in Indonesia.

As a maritime and agrarian country, Indonesia had a lot of farmers and fisherman. They usually led a modest life and chose to walk or cycle for a short distance destination.


Below is called "sepeda onthel", which literally means pedaling bike. It's a heritage from Dutch regime. Generally they are suitable for urban environments and they focus more on comfort and practicality instead of speed or efficiency. The gears are default and it has a front light and backpack frame to transport items.


Not only them, of course, a lot of people were actually using these 2 method. There were even people that open service to escort people to their destination using bike. This is called "ojek sepeda". It was famous in 1970, later on they use motor cycle instead of bike.


Other transportation called "becak" or trishaw, which also use bicycle as its main part, but have an additional seating in front that usually able to fit 2-3 persons.


The other transportation is using horse power called "andong" and able to take 4-5 persons inside. Andong has 2 wheels while another similar version of andong called "dokar" has 4 wheels. They both used in different part of Indonesia and the amount of horse can vary.



The picture below is a traditional transportation using buffaloes power. Commonly used in suburb areas instead of cities downtown. This is called "pedati".


As the time goes on, people are more familiar with motor vehicles. The first common public transportation known is "kopaja". It is similar to bus but the size could vary. It has their own route but can be stopped anywhere unlike the new transjakarta bus which has its own bus stop.




The other famous transportation that still widely used until now is "angkot". It is smaller than kopaja or bus and also has its own route. It is also can be stopped everywhere



However as time goes on, people's mindset is slowly changing, their purchasing power are increasing and also their lifestyle are improving. They prefer using their own car because it is definitely more comfortable, and since the population growth are always rising, the congestion become inevitable. Maybe if they care to try using these-mentioned-transportation back, the congestion wont be as severe. I wont dare to say it will completely dispel congestion, but i guess it will lessen the pollution, using only public transportation or non-motorized vehicle. And of course it will diminish out main problem of "too many vehicles"!

SO, this is my culture, how about yours? ;)



References :
http://dimaszon.blogspot.sg/2013/01/10-transportasi-tradisional-indonesia.html
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadster_(bicycle)



Saturday, 7 February 2015

Case Study on Too Many Vehicles

Hola people! Back again with me and our beloved topic "Too Many Vehicles" *yeayy (boo!). Honestly I am started to feel bored about this topic, but it is fixed already and i cannot do anything to change it, so.. yeah. Here it comes!


This week Im going to do, or only find and analyze actually, a case study about too many vehicles and anything related to it. Since we are aiming for the solutions of this problem then im looking for the success story in overcoming this problem. In fact it happens here, in Singapore, where the government strictly organize driving and car owning regulations. Having the 3rd largest population density after Macau and Monaco with 7618 persons per kilometer square plus having an adequate purchasing power as one of the first world country, Singapore still able to manage its car flow on the road.


After facing a severe congestion problem in 1970, Singapore came back with a handy solution that is to let car owner pay a huge amount for it. Started with the road pricing known as ERP (Electronic Road Pricing), initially called ALS (Area Licensing System), which located in highly congested area such as business district and force people to pay the particular road used. The pricing range from $0 - $5. It gives road users options to pick the other less crowded road or just use public transportation instead. It also required people to get a Vehicle Unit (IU) for ERP.



Another solution is increasing the car price. The price of new car can reach until hundred thousands SGD, without the additional open market value, import duty, goods and service tax, registration fee, and annual road tax which could doubled or worse, tripled the amount you should pay. 


It is so pricey already, not to mention the cumbersome regulation that restricts the quota of COE (Certificate of Entitlement) for the car ownership by conducting an auction twice a month to register it, which valid until 10 years only. After the time, they can re-register their car or buy a new car.


It shows a reduced significant amounts of registered cars after all these rules were implemented, around 1990 until 1993. However then, it increased again especially these few years and i dont think these pricing regulations work that effectively anymore.

Historical Data Chart

So if I reflect on this case, it works because of the price become too high for people to buy, but then when their purchasing power increase the regulations become useless as people doesnt mind the price already. The solutions did work once, but then I dont think it will works anymore. However from this  case i learn that it did work because people cannot afford one or can afford but still thinks it is not worth it and I am still struggling on the way to handle this problem. 


Finally, that's it for this time, this blog is several days late already HAHA. BYE PEEPS!



REFERENCES :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_sovereign_states_and_dependent_territories_by_population_density
http://transportpolicy2013.blogspot.sg/2013/04/singapore-traffic-congestion-solution.html
http://sbr.com.sg/economy/commentary/singapore-reveals-3-economic-solutions-traffic-congestion-asian-peers
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/singapore/car-registrations